Voyages in Drama with Ibsen
home
lectures/booking
translations

criticism
productions
articles
e-texts
•Play It Again•
biography
site map
contact

Play It Again: Re-enacted Story as Tragic Plot
by Brian Johnston

IV. The Plot a Liberating Re-enactment of the Story

As in Oedipus tyrannos, these past events or precedent plots, now take the form of mentally re-enacted agons on-stage. Recollected urgently by the plot, they become intense realities of the present only, transformed now in the light of newly awakened consciousness. Past events take on reality only as objects of present consciousness. It is only in present consciousness that the past can exist (there is no other way it can manifest itself.  The past, therefore,is present consciousness only; only what present consciousness makes of it. And this present consciousness transforms the old events into a new reality. As Ibsen's John Gabriel Borkman proclaims:

    "But what has happened doesn't repeat itself either. The eye transforms the action. And so a newborn eye can transform an old action." [3]

And it is because of this capacity for the newborn eye to transform the old action that the plot, in Sophokles and Ibsen, asserts a human freedom over the inevitable structure of the past. Oedipus cannot change his past: but he can, and does, freely decide tragically to know and acknowledge it, against the urgent advice of Tiresias and Jocasta. 

It is the function of the plots to bring about a vivid resurrection and recreation of past events, which are then experienced as mental actions in the immediate present . This means that the essential actions in Ibsen's plays take place within the characters' minds. In Jennette Lee's words:

    One who is accustomed to think of plot and action as synonymous must dissociate the two terms in taking up the work of Ibsen. His plays have plot in abundance, but nothing happens in them, any more than in one of Mr. Henry James novels. The action takes place in the soul of a character or in the relation between characters. There are few incidents - unless one regards the adventures of the soul as such. [4]

The stories represent an area of the arbitrary, the accidental and external, the realm of seemingly free, spontaneous actions often exhibiting rich variety of detail. It is only when they are reconfigured as plots that the events of the stories reveal the 'closed' structures of inevitable conflict, logical necessity, design, nemesis.

<-prev | top | next->


2. The Ibsen Secret, 95
3. Ibsen; Volume III: Four Plays translated by Brian Johnston, with Rick Davis, Lyme, N.H. Smith and Kraus 1998) p. 168
4.
The Ibsen Secret 88-89